A Jim Carrey Exit Would Be Sonic 3's Worst Nightmare

Jim Carrey revealed that he intends to retire from acting after Sonic the Hedgehog 2, which might just spell doom for the third film in the successful video game movie franchise. Across all the media over the years, a massive part of Sonic's identity is tied to Eggman. For the trilogy to conclude without Jim Carrey's interpretation of the character would be more than disappointing. It'd be a disaster in numerous ways.

Dr. Robotnik, also known as Eggman, is a major fixture of the Sonic the Hedgehog franchise. He's the Blue Blur's arch-nemesis and most recurring enemy. He's vexed Sonic and his friends since the very first game in 1991 and has generally been the most consistent enemy across the games, comics, and cartoons. His popularity is unmistakable as well. There are very few games in which he doesn't rear his head, even if he isn't the primary antagonist, such as the case of Sonic Heroes or Sonic and the Secret Rings.

Related: Why Jim Carrey's Eggman Mustache Is So Much Bigger In Sonic 2

Losing Jim Carrey would be a major downgrade for the Sonic the Hedgehog movies, both because of Carrey's portrayal and because of what the character himself brings to the series. Following the almost too perfect casting of Carrey's Eggman in Sonic the Hedgehog would be a herculean task. What's more, Eggman is instrumental in ensuring that the set-up Sonic Adventure 2 storyline works properly. If Sonic Adventure 2 is indeed the plot being primarily pulled from, then Eggman not being in the sequel would doom the character to missing out on the best developments his character's ever had in the games.

At this point, replacing the Eggman would be virtually impossible. Jim Carrey's Dr. Robotnik has become a staple of these films, in no small part due to his endearingly over-the-top portrayal. He brings an energy to the character that no one else can imitate, making any effort to recast him unthinkable. Even without recasting him, however, replacing Eggman as the primary antagonist would be an uphill battle as the primary contender for that role in the next Sonic movie, G.U.N, represents a definite step backward. Traditionally represented as a fairly stock military splinter group, G.U.N remained largely faceless until 2005's derided Shadow the Hedgehog, making them nowhere near as memorable. Unfortunately, the implied direction with Shadow also doesn't inspire confidence.

Not only would Carrey's exit rob the series of one of its best elements, but the implied story of the next movie essentially requires Eggman's presence. Eggman plays an integral role in the entire story of Sonic Adventure 2, the debut game of Shadow the Hedgehog, to the point that his character is critically important to Shadow's own character arc. Unlike with Knuckles in Sonic 2, Eggman doesn't manipulate Shadow. They share a common objective in the destruction of G.U.N and work together throughout the game. Shadow acts entirely of his own free will. The tease of the next movie, however, heavily implies that it will be forgoing that arc entirely in favor of having Shadow simply be a weapon used by G.U.N to neutralize Sonic. This would only have the effect of robbing the character of his agency in the story by making him yet another puppet, just with someone else pulling the strings.

Perhaps the most unfortunate thing lost with a Jim Carrey exit would be the lack of getting to see the live-action Eggman reach his videogame counterpart's narrative potential on the big screen. Making him more than just a mustache-twirling evil scientist, Sonic Adventure 2 added more layers of complexity that contributed to Eggman being a more well-rounded character. This was best represented in what's almost universally seen as the best Eggman moment in any Sonic game, wherein he talks to fellow genius, Tails, about his admiration of his grandfather. That moment in the game represents his best character arc in 30 years of games. If Jim Carrey truly does retire from acting after Sonic the Hedgehog 2, the next film will almost certainly be worse off for it.

Next: Sonic 2’s Knuckles Villain Arc Created A Major Sonic 3 Problem

from ScreenRant - Feed

Post a Comment